Office Hours
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking, Investment Services, Annuities
Paul Watzlavik
Office Hours
Address
Newburgh, IN 47630
Would you like to create a personalized quote?
Would you like to create a personalized quote?
Office Info
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking, Investment Services, Annuities
Office Info
Simple Insights®
ATV safety tips
ATV safety tips
Taking the proper ATV safety steps can help keep you and your family safe while you enjoy your riding experience.
Understanding the insurance premium audit process
Understanding the insurance premium audit process
As a business owner, you may be contacted to complete an insurance premium audit. Learn what that is and how you can be ready.
Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself
Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself
To combat auto repair costs that keep climbing, some auto maintenance can be done at home. Here are ones that are usually do-it-yourself.
Social Media
Viewing team member 1 of 12
Amanda Kirby
Office Manager
License #928743
Amanda is approaching 13 years with our agency, and throughout this time, she has proven to be an invaluable and trusted member of our team. Since her early days with us during college, Amanda has built extensive expertise and is licensed in Auto, Home, Life, and Health Insurance across Indiana, Kentucky, and Illinois. She is deeply committed to helping individuals and families in our community protect what matters most by providing reliable insurance coverage along with exceptional, personalized service.
Outside of her professional role, Amanda leads a rich and fulfilling life. She treasures quality time with her husband, Brad, their son, Calvin, and their beloved chocolate Lab, Milo. Amanda is also an avid sports enthusiast and loves exploring new destinations whenever she gets the chance. Her passion, dedication, and warm personality not only make her an outstanding insurance professional but also a cherished member of our agency family.
Viewing team member 2 of 12
Taylor Greibe
License #4160884
Chelsey joined our team in 2025 and brings extensive experience in the insurance industry. She is here to assist you with all your insurance needs!
Viewing team member 3 of 12
Jason Cavins
Insurance Account Representative
License #578459
Jason joined our team in 2025 and brings extensive experience in the insurance industry. He is here to assist you with all your insurance needs!
Viewing team member 4 of 12
Dylan Ande
Insurance Account Representative
License #4006958
Dylan joined our team in 2025 and brings extensive experience in the insurance industry. He is here to assist you with all your insurance needs!
Viewing team member 5 of 12
Daniel Watzlavik
Auto/Home/Life Insurance Rep
License #3532790
In 2019, Paul's son, Dan, enthusiastically joined the family business, eager to contribute to the improvement of our community and serve our valued customers. Dan graduated from Purdue University in 2015, achieving a degree in Agricultural Economics. His love for the outdoors is evident, as he relishes spending time in nature with his wife and their two beloved dogs.
Dan actively engages in community initiatives, dedicating his time and efforts to events like Walking for Dreams and volunteering at his local Parish. As our Life Insurance Lead, Dan is passionate about ensuring that you and your family are adequately protected. He welcomes the opportunity to guide you through the process of selecting the right life insurance coverage, providing assurance for the future.
Viewing team member 6 of 12
Sarah Watzlavik
Personal Account Representative
License #3859252
Sarah, Paul's daughter, joined our team in 2022. Following in the footsteps of her family, Sarah graduated from Purdue University and initially pursued a career in San Francisco. However, after gaining experience in the bustling city, she felt drawn back home to learn and contribute to the family business.
During her leisure time, Sarah finds joy in the company of friends and explores her passion for travel and culinary adventures. She also cherishes moments spent with her mother, bonding over the latest Netflix shows. Sarah's arrival has brought a fresh perspective to our team, and she is committed to providing exceptional service to our valued customers.
Viewing team member 7 of 12
Ashley Ford
Auto/Home/Life Insurance Rep
License #3976159
Ashley is known for her unwavering love for assisting others, which is evident by the constant smile that graces her face. With a diverse background and extensive customer service expertise, she is well-equipped to cater to various needs. Ashley's true passion lies in creating unforgettable moments with her daughter, Gabrielle, as well as cherishing quality time with loved ones. In her spare time, she enjoys indulging in her creative side through crafting and has an affinity for organizing, especially for others. With hopes of exploring new destinations, Ashley eagerly anticipates more travel adventures in the future.
Viewing team member 8 of 12
Sinclair Jones
Insurance Account Representative
License #4029567
Sinclair enjoys attending local events and supporting local businesses, specifically those in downtown Evansville. She enjoys travel, learning new things and spending time with friends and family. As a vital member of our service team, Sinclair is ready to help you and your family with all of your insurance needs.
Viewing team member 9 of 12
Chelsey Conrad
Account Representative
License #4122352
Chelsey joined our team in 2025 and brings extensive experience in the insurance industry. She is here to assist you with all your insurance needs!
Viewing team member 10 of 12
Maria Ramirez
Insurance Account Representative
License #4143060
Maria joined our team in 2025 and brings extensive experience in the insurance industry. She is here to assist you with all your insurance needs!
Viewing team member 11 of 12
Chris Kelly
Auto/Home/Life Insurance Rep
License #643947
Chris Kelly is an experienced insurance professional with an MBA, a proud father of two, and a U.S. Army Veteran. His service background and business education shape his customer-first approach—prioritizing honesty, clarity, and tailored coverage. He has been serving the Evansville Newburgh area since 2019. Chris works hard to ensure every customer is protected with the right policy at the right value.
Viewing team member 12 of 12
Abby Hollingsworth
License #4177243
Abby joined our team in 2025 and brings extensive experience in the insurance industry. She is here to assist you with all your insurance needs!
https://www.indeed.com/job/office-representative-7637cdee26242322
Click to view all of Paul's current openings!